52: Week Nine
Review
Credits
- Words: Geoff Johns, Grant Morrison, Greg Rucka, and Mark Waid
- Art: Keith Giffen and Shawn Moll
- Inks: Tom Nguyen
- Colors: David Baron
- Story Title: Dream Of America
- Publisher: DC Comics
- Price: $2.99
- Release Date: Jul 6, 2006
Posted by Kenneth Gallant on Jul 10, 2006
Tags: 52, dc, giffen, johns, moll, morrison, rucka, waid
Week Nine heats up when John Henry Irons learns his niece Natasha has undergone some interesting changes after volunteering for Lex Luthor’s meta-gene experiment.
Well, I must say I didn’t see this coming, but I thought the machinations of Lex Luthor became ever so apparent. Now this is the Lex Luthor I know and despise as a super villain, and it’s nice to see his diabolical presence felt here in Week Nine. I was also beginning to think this series was lacking some bite, but after the events that unfolded here I am taking that back.
The issue opens with an irate John Henry Irons storming Lexcorp in search of his niece Natasha. He’s feeling so incensed over being manipulated by Lex after he had his physiology altered and then having lured his niece (down to Lexcorp) to take part in his meta-gene experiment. John physically attacks Lex, but before the confrontation can escalate, Natasha jumps into the fray now fully transformed into something very powerful. Of course John is shocked by the change and he is unexpectedly forced to deal with her brashness. Meanwhile, on an unknown planet Animal Man, Adam Strange and Starfire continue to struggle against The God of the Pursuit and then in Gotham, Vic Sage reveals his true identity to Montoya.
I think there is a considerable amount of plot development here for an issue written in tandem by the likes of Johns, Morrison, Rucka and Waid. It’s hard to tell who wrote what part, but honestly I don’t think it really matters. What is important though is the conflict between John and his niece. I thought it was needed here, since I am finding this series to be a little on the tepid side in terms of sporting a bona fide villain.
The art of Shawn Moll didn’t really impress me much. I know that Keith Giffen is doing all the breakdowns for this series, but not even his skilled artistry could help the work gracing this issue stand out for me. I found it to be bland and not very dynamic, and that’s too bad because I thought the brewing conflict between John and Natasha would have had more dramatic impact with a better artist onboard to illuminate that family squabble.
Overall though, I found this issue to be entertaining for the most part. I do think it’s hard to keep this book consistent given the weekly format, and I found the focus on this one appropriate given the conflict between John and his niece. I think though that after nine issues I am still feeling like this series is lacking a key ingredient, and maybe Lex Luthor will fill that bill. I guess only time will tell.
Related content
Related Headlines
- Enter the World of 52 - written by Frederik Hautain on May 7, 2006
- 52 Breaks the Bank - written by Frederik Hautain on Jan 26, 2006
- DC Ups Infinite Crisis #7 Page Count - written by Frederik Hautain on Apr 24, 2006
- 52 to Feature Origin Back-Ups - written by Frederik Hautain on Jul 16, 2006
- 52 #1 Sneak Peek - written by Frederik Hautain on May 9, 2006
Related Lowdowns
- Flash-Forward: Wally West - written by Fletch Adams on Jun 17, 2009
- Flash-back: Jay Garrick - written by Fletch Adams on Apr 29, 2009
- Up for Another Weekly Countdown? - written by Ricardo Torres on Apr 18, 2007
- Examining World War III - written by Andy Oliver on Apr 22, 2007
- Flash-Point: Bart Allen - written by Fletch Adams on Jun 24, 2009
Related Reviews
- 52: Week Twenty-Seven - written by Eric Lindberg on Nov 10, 2006
- 52: Week Fifteen - written by Eric Lindberg on Aug 21, 2006
- 52: Week Five - written by Eric Lindberg on Jun 8, 2006
- 52: Week Seventeen - written by Eric Lindberg on Sep 3, 2006
- 52: Week Fifty-One - written by Eric Lindberg on Apr 25, 2007
Related Columns
- Walking Away from the JSA - written by William Gatevackes on Apr 28, 2009
- Is He Dead? - written by William Gatevackes on May 12, 2008
- Why Y Works - written by Mark Steensland on Dec 29, 2005
- ?Final? Finally Arrives - written by William Gatevackes on May 26, 2008
- The Secret Jewish History of… – Part Two - written by Jason Berek Lewis on Jun 12, 2007
Comments
In order to post a comment you have to be logged in. Don't have a profile yet? Register now!
Saga #1 Gets 5th Printing
Press release by Richard Boom
SAGA #1's fourth printing is on shelves today, but it sold out at the distributor before even arriving in stores, ...
Ame-Comi Girls Debut Digitally
Press release by Richard Boom
If you’re looking for new digital comics to read over the long Memorial Day weekend we’ve got just the ...
The Dynamite Art of Alex Ross On ComiXology
Press release by Richard Boom
The Dynamite Art of Alex Ross is now available digitally on ComiXology! Already printed as a hit hardcover ...
READ ALL HEADLINES