Astonishing X-Men #17
Review
Credits
- Words: Joss Whedon
- Art: John Cassaday
- Inks: John Cassaday
- Colors: Laura Martin
- Story Title: N/A
- Publisher: Marvel Comics
- Price: $2.99
- Release Date: Sep 20, 2006
Posted by Tonya Crawford on Sep 22, 2006
Tags: astonishing x-men, cassaday, marvel, whedon
The White Queen spins a fairy tale for Kitty that can only lead to trouble, SWORD’s mole at the mansion is revealed, questions are answered and new ones are asked.
As this title settles into a monthly schedule for the rest of writer Joss Whedon’s run, the story picks up pace. Whedon continues to display an excellent grasp of character, pacing and plot as well as a love and understanding of X-Men history and characterization. He cherry picks some of the best elements from former X-Men writers like Chris Claremont and Grant Morrison and then expands on those elements and ideas, taking them in new and exciting directions and taking the reader with them.
This issue opens with a joyous event – the birth of Kitty and Peter’s son, Michael. Yeahbuhwhat?! The White Queen (A.K.A. "Perfection") is messing with Kitty’s mind for the Hellfire Club’s nefarious purposes. Meanwhile, SWORD struggles to catch up with Danger and Ord but those two engines of destruction are at least two steps ahead. Enemies abound and the X-Men are at their lowest ebb. The thing is, the X-Men can be taken down, but they are a lot harder to keep down....
One of the key things with this series so far is how Whedon has cleverly continued to lead readers along by offering up mysteries and enigmas and slowly doling out the solutions, all the while leading to more mysteries. He times the revelations with stopwatch precision, knowing exactly the right moments to spring them on the readers with the snap of a Jack-in-the-Box.
Beyond the impeccable pacing, Whedon infuses these characters with more heart than your average comic book character. The best example of this is Kitty’s part of the story. The White Queen has immersed Kitty in a psychoactive scenario that shows the strength and steel in this young woman, as well as how far she is willing to go for love and family.
There is humor here as well. Wolverine turned into an innocent little boy at the turn of the last century has been consistently funny and twisted. Here that subplot has a payoff that is note perfect with a little wink and nod to the fans.
John Cassaday still turns out his usual beautiful, expressive artwork with its emphasis on realism. His attention to detail really shines through with the little touches – like the way Beast’s fur or a character’s hair moves. He is ably added and abetted by the too-often unsung colorist Laura Martin. Martin must convincingly hue no less than four separate environments and enough action, explosions, and rubble for a Michael Bay movie. She does it all without a single miscolored moment.
Astonishing X-Men has consistently been the best of Marvel’s "X" titles and is certainly a candidate for being the best-written and penciled series of Marvel’s entire line. The series is always a surprise, twisting and turning, keeping the reader guessing and then gasping for breath. There is heart, humor, action, adventure and characters you know and love. This is a big part of what comic books are all about; so jump on and see where the Mr. Whedon’s wild ride is going.
Related content
Related Headlines
- Astonishing X-Men #14 Sneak Peek - written by Frederik Hautain on Apr 4, 2006
- X-Men Motion Comic Concludes Today on iTunes - written by Fletch Adams on Jan 6, 2010
- Astonishing Whedon & Cassaday Win Eisners - written by Frederik Hautain on Jul 23, 2006
- Astonishing X-Men #19 Variant Revealed - written by Frederik Hautain on Dec 8, 2006
- MarvelFest NYC 2009 Announces Full Guest List - written by Fletch Adams on Oct 27, 2009
Related Lowdowns
- Nothing Short Of Astonishing - written by Tommy Marx on Jan 19, 2006
- Downright Astonishing - written by Jan Rosenfeld on May 28, 2008
- New to the Mansion - Part I - written by Sam Moyerman on Apr 11, 2006
- Spider-Man: The Other Conference Call - written by Jp Dorigo on Aug 31, 2005
- Avengers, Ultimately - written by Sam Moyerman on Mar 6, 2006
Related Reviews
- Giant Size Astonishing X-Men #1 - written by Tonya Crawford on May 30, 2008
- Astonishing X-Men #22 - written by Tonya Crawford on Aug 26, 2007
- Astonishing X-Men #12 - written by Dexter K Flowers on Sep 2, 2005
- Astonishing X-Men #13 - written by Tonya Crawford on Feb 23, 2006
- Astonishing X-Men #14 - written by Aaron Stueve on Apr 28, 2006
Related Columns
- Devouring the Competition - written by William Gatevackes on Oct 15, 2007
- Looking In At The Outsiders - written by William Gatevackes on Nov 12, 2007
- Keeping Secrets - written by J P Dorigo on Nov 11, 2007
- Death?s Head: Keeping the Peace.. with Violence - written by Tony Ingram on Apr 30, 2008
- Death Sells, Rebirths Not So Much - written by William Gatevackes on Jun 30, 2009
Comments
In order to post a comment you have to be logged in. Don't have a profile yet? Register now!
Action Lab Teases Jack Hammer Comic Series
Press release by VashNL
Independent comic book series collected and completed this summer.
First Ever Star Trek/Doctor Who Crossover Coming in May from IDW
Press release by Frederik Hautain
IDW Publishing will make history when two of the greatest science-fiction properties of all time come together in ...
Adam Warrock Releases "You Dare Call That Thing Human?!?"
Press release by Richard Boom
The Internet's Foremost Comic Book Rapper, Adam WarRock, has released his second full-length album, You Dare Call ...
READ ALL HEADLINES