Overview

Athena #1

Review

Share this review

  • Button Delicious
  • Bttn Digg
  • Bttn Facebook
  • Bttn Ff
  • Bttn Myspace
  • Bttn Stumble
  • Bttn Twitter
  • Bttn Reddit

Athena #1

Credits

  • Words: Doug Murray
  • Art: Paul Renaud & Fabiano Neves
  • Colors: Marcelo Maiolo & Paul Renaud
  • Publisher: Dynamite Entertainment
  • Price: $3.50
  • Release Date: Sep 15, 2009

On a grass covered slope, near Athens, a naked woman is sound asleep. She is brought to the hospital and has amnesia. That sounds simple, but when she awakens she is drawn towards the historical Parthenon where she contemplates the ruins, which do not seem to match her memories at all...while walking around the ruins she is attacked by bestial men, but with lightning from her eyes she defends herself, astonished yet unknowing.

An owl and a nameless and bodiless presence grant her a new identity as Athena Olympios, who ventures to New York to work as a Police Detective. The story picks up years later at the exact moment she goes undercover and gets mixed up with some bad people. The mysterious owl (the mystical attribute to the Goddess Athena) comes to the rescue and Athena the human is transformed into the full-fledged Goddess of Wisdom & Crafts, War & Justice.

The myth of Athena is effectively told via words by Doug Murray and pencils/colors of French top artist Paul Renaud, whose soft rendering-style makes for eye-popping artwork. Renaud also makes sure that Athena's transcendent awakening, her contemplating as well as the brutal attack on Akropolis, is carried out with luscious details and vibrant colors to ensure eye-candy and apt storytelling.

With Athena's move to New York City, artist Fabiano Neves takes over with stunning women and big-chested thugs to finish the story with a smashing cliffhanger!

In regards to the artwork there is really no reason at all to be squeamish. The story presents an interesting take on one of the most loved mythological beings from Old Greece. Too bad the story reads - at this point -  too much like a good-girl/bad-guys story to be more enjoyable. The stage is set up nicely, but somehow the "chica-cop goes Miss Congeniality" routine seems to be lacking intensity and in the case of "undercover cop knows too much and must get whacked" it just is not logical.

Still, I am looking forward to the next issue based mostly in regards to the lovely visuals though. I would love it if writer Doug Murray would up the story and introduce more mythologies in the form of more deities, not attributes. And the fact that some men see Athena and think aloud "I know you from somewhere" makes me wonder about an extra layer story-wise that will show up during the course of this series of four issues.

Related content

Related Headlines

Related Lowdowns

Related Reviews

Comments

  • Tonya Crawford

    Tonya Crawford Sep 21, 2009 at 8:43pm

    Okay, has the world gone nuts or is it just me?! This comic was TERRIBLE!!! Athena #1, how do I hate you? Let me count the ways.....

    1) Okay, I can live with cheesecake most of the time. As a female comic book reader I kind of HAVE to but THIS.... Has the artist EVER visited a hospital in his life?! I can assure you hospital gowns DO NOT fit like this. Plus, panel after panel of naked butt shots for little other reason than to put a naked butt in the panel.

    2) Plot holes you could drive a Mack truck through.... Let's see... we clearly see the doctor order a guard to stay on duty outside Athena's room. And yet, somehow, she manages to walk out. Even IF we want to cut a little slack and say "Okay, well, maybe the guard had to go to the bathroom or he was really sucky at his job and fell asleep" we've stiil got A WHOLE HOSPITAL FULL OF PEOPLE WHO ARE GOING TO LET A PATIENT WALK OUT (wearing the world's shortest, tightest hospital gown)?!?! And if THAT wasn't enough, said Athena is able to, somehow, WALK through the city (in the world's shortest, tightest hospital gown) without ANYONE noticing and maybe, I dunno, stopping her, asking if she's okay, CALLING THE FREAKING COPS?!?!

    3) Leaps in logic....We meet Athena's supporting cast of fellow cops. WHO ARE THESE PEOPLE?! I mean, go back and look -- are ANY of these people given ACTUAL NAMES HERE?!?!?! And then, she's put in the 'undercover mission' -- um, helllloooo WHO is this 'bad guy' they're supposedly after? You will notice HE isn't named either. And, WHY are the police after him, hmmm? Is he a gun runner? Drug dealer? Pimp? WHAT?!?! We're never told. We're just told 'he's bad' (Mmkay?). And THEN Athena is supposed to be competing in some kind of 'American Idol' like competition? What, huh? Why? And, most of all, this requires her to wear a skimpy red minidress and thigh high red boots... WHY?

    4) "Let's make you fabulous!" Umm, right, because Athena with her tight sweater, long, artfully mussed blonde hair, and perfect lips is just SUCH a dog that she needs a woman bursting in the door waving a makeup palatte around to make herself into something striking. Yeaahhh....

    5) Wimpiest cop EVER! Seriously, I know that TV and comic books like to make their characters seem more badass than usual. How many times have we seen heroes take a lickin' and keep on tickin' and we know that any NORMAL human would be in traction for a month over a beating like that. But THIS goes in the freakin' OPPOSITE direction! I mean, the art CLEARLY shows that bullet grazes Athena's arm and a would that would take a few hours to clean and stich closed suddenly leaves her "weak" and "resting" in the hospital for a couple of DAYS?! Geezus I've fallen off my BIKE and gotten worse scrapes than that!!!

    6) And finally, there is the (unnamed) cop who is (I presume) going to end up being Athena's new partner... A man who is drawn as if he walked straight out of a "Jem and the Holograms" music video. Yes I WENT there!!!

    I will allow THIS and THIS much only. We DO learn the name of Athena's cop partner.... In the FLIP BOOK in the BACK in a story that is supposed to be taking place SEVERAL MONTHS AFTER THIS OPENING STORY ARC!!!

    Arrggghhhhh!!!! The SHEER stupidity here is just too much! Someone, ANYONE, Please tell me I'm NOT the only one to see how BADLY put together this comic is! Does it have potential? Wellll, maybe. But they're going to have to work a HELL of a lot harder to tighten up the story, plug the plot holes and quit with the pointless cheesecake before I'll willingly look at it again.

    There, I've ranted.

  • Bart Croonenborghs

    Bart Croonenborghs Sep 22, 2009 at 4:04am

    It seems, my dear, that your Comics Scanning Power have failed you! Quick, get this woman more hot chocolate! :)

  • Tonya Crawford

    Tonya Crawford Sep 22, 2009 at 9:16am

    My "Comics Scanning Power" has 'failed' me? In what way?

  • Bart Croonenborghs

    Bart Croonenborghs Sep 22, 2009 at 9:28am

    In a avoid-this-comic-at-all-costs kind of way ofcourse :)

  • Tonya Crawford

    Tonya Crawford Sep 22, 2009 at 11:15am

    Ah. Got it. Well, in all acutality, this was a comp comic for review. Since I'm still on sabbatical, no review. Even if I HADN'T been on sabbatical I wouldn't have reviewed it because, as you can see from the rant above, I don't think I could have quite kept my ire in check.

In order to post a comment you have to be logged in. Don't have a profile yet? Register now!

Latest headlines

READ ALL HEADLINES

Latest comments
Comics Discussion
Broken Frontier on Facebook