Power Girl #2
Review
Credits
- Words: Justin Gray & Jimmy Palmiotti
- Art: Amanda Conner
- Colors: Paul Mounts
- Story Title: Unleashing the Beast
- Publisher: DC Comics
- Price: $2.99
- Release Date: Jun 18, 2009
Posted by Tonya Crawford on Jun 20, 2009
Tags: amanda conner, dc comics, jimmy palmiotti, justin gray, power girl
The Ultra-Humanite’s plot is revealed but does even Power Girl have a chance at stopping him?
After a fun and stellar first issue the second installment of this ongoing series makes a couple of missteps. The question is, can it rebound and find its footing again?
Ultra-Humanite has found what he believes is the perfect cure for his condition – he intends to transplant his brain into Power Girl’s body. Provoked by her taunting, however, he reveals to her what he purports to be the true story of his origin – a tale fraught with tragedy, hubris and insanity.
Longtime DC Comics fans will likely be upset here as the Ultra-Humanite’s back-story gets a major reboot. Theoretically this change in the past is a result of either or both Infinite Crisis and Final Crisis but the fact that this isn’t really made clear leads to some serious head scratching as fans try to figure out how all of this might or might not fit in with what has gone before. The bigger question is, of course, whether Ultra-Humanite even necessarily needed a new origin but, in all fairness, Gray and Palmiotti do streamline things quite a bit here which is always good for newer readers and those who do not have an encyclopedic knowledge of DC’s characters. The biggest problem here is that the whole thing comes across as a little too cliché. The entire issue is really devoted to Ultra-Humanite and his rant-filled excuse for a flashback is something straight out of the Silver Age… and not in a good way. It feels more like an info dump than a natural outgrowth of the story. Along those same lines, the sequences where the title’s new supporting cast huddles in safety inside Starrware’s new headquarters building and fearfully contemplate the madness outside goes on entirely too long and the dialogue gets repetitive. This leads to the sequence feeling like padding to try to bolster a thin story.
Amanda Conner’s artwork is, in contrast, as flawless as ever. She makes the fight scenes look harsh and brutal despite her cartoony style. As always she also does excellent work on the facial features. Even when Power Girl is effectively gagged and unable to speak Conner’s work perfectly conveys everything that the character is thinking and feeling and not a single word of dialogue is even needed there.
While this issue had some serious pacing problems Gray and Palmiotti have proven time and time again on other titles that they know how to tell a good story, that they know how to draw readers in, and that they know how to keep the action and the tension up without resorting to obvious clichés and tropes. Here is hoping that the problems with this issue are merely a minor blip on the radar and that, with the next installment, the story will again find its footing and finish with a bang – after all, could you expect anything less from the blonde bombshell that is Power Girl?
Related content
Related Headlines
- Winick and Basri Form Power Girl's New Team - written by Richard Boom on Mar 19, 2010
- Radical's Plans for FCBD 2010 - written by Richard Boom on Jan 16, 2010
- Preview: Time Bomb #2 - written by Frederik Hautain on Sep 3, 2010
- Preview: Time Bomb #3 - written by Richard Boom on Dec 17, 2010
- Image Explores The Deadlands - written by Richard Boom on Mar 5, 2011
Related Lowdowns
- Jonah Hex Puts Up with Jimmy Palmiotti for 50... - written by Richard Boom on Dec 4, 2009
- MegaCon 2010: DC Nation Panel Report - written by Noel Bartocci on Mar 14, 2010
- Santa Holds The Gun - written by Frederik Hautain on Nov 24, 2004
- MegaCon 2010: Writing Genre Fiction Panel - written by Noel Bartocci on Mar 17, 2010
- "Hex" Crime - written by James Wortman on Jun 21, 2010
Related Reviews
- Jonah Hex #44 - written by Tonya Crawford on Jun 9, 2009
- Freedom Fighters #1 - written by Nathan Wilson on Sep 3, 2010
- All-Star Western #1 - written by JasonClyma on Sep 30, 2011
- Power Girl #24 - written by Chad Bonin on May 26, 2011
- The Punisher Red Xmas - written by Kert Mcafee on Dec 31, 2004
Related Columns
- Back to the Past, Ahead to the Future - written by William Gatevackes on Dec 22, 2009
- Final Milestone Reached - written by William Gatevackes on Feb 2, 2010
- Everybody Wave! - written by William Gatevackes on Mar 2, 2010
- Everything New Is New Again - written by William Gatevackes on May 5, 2009
- Broken Arrow - written by William Gatevackes on Jun 22, 2010
Comments
-
Eric Lindberg Jun 20, 2009 at 10:38am
Yeah, the Humanite retcon was kind of odd. If they took out the modern clothing styles and reference to PETA, it would have worked fine. Not sure why they wanted to update it and potentially screw up his history. We could always chalk this up to the Humanite's garbled memories. Transplanting your brain around that much has gotta cause some damage.
-
Andy Oliver Jun 21, 2009 at 11:11am
Yeah agreed on the Ultra-Humanite front. The first coupla issues have been a little disappointing.
In order to post a comment you have to be logged in. Don't have a profile yet? Register now!
Adam Warrock Releases "You Dare Call That Thing Human?!?"
Press release by Richard Boom
The Internet's Foremost Comic Book Rapper, Adam WarRock, has released his second full-length album, You Dare Call ...
Camilla d'Errico No Ordinary Love Limited-Edition Bust
Press release by Richard Boom
One of the brightest stars of pop-surrealism, Camilla d'Errico is known as an artist, designer and graphic ...
Cosmic Times presents Arthur: The Legend Continues
Press release by Richard Boom
With the world as we know it gone, mankind is on the verge of extinction yet still struggling to find purpose and ...
READ ALL HEADLINES