In 2025, American cartoonist and movie critic Nathan Gelgud deflated the egos of people who claim to be passionate about cinema with his pocked-sized collection of comic strips called Reel Politik. He’s back with Round Two and, to get to the point, No Concessions! is funnier than ever.
One of many things that makes Gelgud’s work so relatable isn’t just the Instagram-ready format he appears to prefer, but the irony of using it to attack people who arguably struggle to have coherent views precisely because of how social media has decimated attention spans. One can almost sense his tongue firmly in cheek as he sets about skewering everyone and everything from actors and critics to film festivals, and people who support Donald Trump.
Another thing that makes these comics so amusing is the inescapable kernel of truth they carry within them. The running gags echo what contemporary filmmakers feel about how modern cinephiles ‘consume’ art. Ridley Scott, for instance, has attacked what he referred to as a smartphone-obsessed generation that was incapable of paying attention to long-form storytelling. In 2000, filmmaker John Waters went so far as to write and direct a film called Cecil B. Demented (also referenced here), about a band of ‘outlaw filmmakers’ attempting a revolution by kidnapping a popular actress.
The shared joke in these pages is that all revolutions must fail when confronted with the reality of capitalism. It happens time and again, as Gelgud’s characters try to become heroes only to be weighed down by more prosaic concerns.
It isn’t just a series of unconnected panels either. Apart from humorous asides — like the appearance of dogs with names like Jean-Luc Dogard, Agnés Vardog, and Alfred Hitchcockerspaniel — there’s a parallel story involving an amateur film on militant organization Weather Underground, the kidnapping of an A-list actress named Starlet Bohannon, a cake-eating cult, militant nurses, and billionaires on a yacht plotting to control the world using AI. The zanier the plot, the smarter the jokes become.
This is a book that doesn’t pander to its audience. “If you can sit still for three and a half hours of The Brutalist,” says one wannabe revolutionary, “you can do it for two hours to make a new society.” It is a snide remark that works even for those who haven’t watched the Oscar-winning film mentioned.
In an interview discussing how he came up with Sandra the witch, Skip the manager, or Hal the duck, the cartoonist recently made an interesting comment about how his characters have a “no sellout ethos” and choose a revolutionary ethos that is completely foreign to their contemporaries. That is telling because of how it taps into Gen Z concerns. On the one hand are economic realities that normalize the notion of ‘monetizing the self’. On the other is the still-prevalent criticism that equates high-paying jobs with a betrayal of ideals.
Like many artists, Gelgud doesn’t take sides. He simply lets his characters grapple with their crises and allows the reader to decide whether that warrants a laugh. To his credit, it almost always does.
Nathan Gelgud (W/A) • Drawn & Quarterly, $20.00
Buy online from Gosh! Comics here
Review by Lindsay Pereira












